Bento Review: Battlestar Galactica Memorial

DIG014260_1._SX360_QL80_TTD_

Normally, I’d avoid a comic based on a licensed property like the proverbial plague, but Comics Bento just ships stuff, so I end up with stuff I normally wouldn’t, like that Youngblood volume, or this trade from Dynamite based off the original Battlestar Galactica.

How was it?  See after the cut.

The problem with most licensed comics is that the stories and such are greatly restrained by the original source material.  Take this volume, for example.  Now, this version of Battlestar Galactica has been off the air for decades, there’s not going to be more added to this series, and some of the original cast is rather dead.  That doesn’t really change much.  The characters are still drawn to look like the actors who played them, and it’s not as if they can suddenly kill off half the cast of characters.  A comic based on a licensed property still has to fit into the narrative it’s based off.

That said, this volume did catch my eye for two reasons.

  1. The writers of this volume were Dan Abnett and Andy Lanning, AKA the two guys who made Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy hot again.  Yes, these guys revived Marvel’s cosmic line and created the line of the Guardians that have since appeared in the movie baring the name, a new concept off the original Guardians being a completely different team based in the distant future.
  2. It’s an alternate timeline story, and I’ve always been a sucker for those, since it allows creators to do stuff that normally wouldn’t be possible.

That said…the volume wasn’t that good, all told.  Decent artwork, but the story itself seems rather dull.

The volume picks up with a Cylon attack on the Galactica.  Child scientist Zee has some temporal weapons he claims are the only path to victory, so he sends out Apollo and Starbuck on the only two vipers equipped with the weapons in question.  Something goes wrong and Apollo and Starbuck are blasted to an alternate time line where Adama was a diplomat instead of a battlestar commander, and the Cylons have more or less won.

Now, this could have been cool.  We could have seen more alternate versions of the original characters, but aside from Baltar being a cyborg with the brain of a Cylon Imperious Leader drone, and Zee being evil, there isn’t much here.  Apollo and Starbuck are separated.  Starbuck gets captured and winds up in a cell with…himself.  But this Starbuck is fatter, hairier, and only out for himself.  He’s been using the Galactica as a pirate ship, and it takes the clean-shaven version of himself to rouse his conscience enough to rescue the other prisoners and then go to the defense of the resistance that Adama is commanding.

Apollo, meanwhile, finds said resistance and rallies them to be braver.  In this time line, Apollo and Boxey are dead, and his wife survived.  Adama is a beaten man.

What do you want to bet that by the time this story is over, Starbuck and Apollo have rallied both the separate groups to work together and really hit the Cylons hard?  Come on, you know that’s coming.

I found it a bit weak.  There could have been more.  And how come no one recognizes anyone until Apollo sees the alternate Adama?  He didn’t recognize Boomer?  And Starbuck didn’t recognize himself right away?  Even the alternate one should have known his own face and voice when he saw it.  Nope, no one sees it.

Maybe the problem is that the original BSG wasn’t the sort of series that loans itself well to a serious look at modern science fiction.  I like the old show, but there’s a reason the recent revamp is so much better.

Granted, anything in corporate comics limits creativity for creators, but I just felt mildly disappointed by this volume all told.  Let’s give it five out of ten temporal vipers.

NEXT BOOK:  It’s a Marvel Masterworks of Silver Age Iron Man stories, as written by Stan Lee.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Bento Review: Battlestar Galactica Memorial”

      1. It came out shortly after the original Star Wars. Technically, it was an achievement at that time to adapt the special effects to the limitations of TV sets. The imagery was considered similar to that of the movie. I guess I’m revealing my age category…

        Like

      2. Not too much. If I remember right, George Lucas even threatened a lawsuit over the original show. I’m sure it was intended as a cash-in, because that’s what Hollywood does.

        This particular trade came with my Comic Bento subscription, and I have no idea off-hand how old it is, so I am reluctant to call it a Star Wars cash-in.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s